With Summit County starting the foreclosure process against Chapel Hill Mall, two mayors of neighboring cities offered their thoughts on potential future uses for the site, where current mall businesses could relocate to, and the cities’ role in a potential redevelopment of the property.
Chapel Hill Mall again avoided having its utilities shut off earlier this month, but now Summit County plans to begin foreclosure proceedings for delinquent property taxes — its owner owes nearly $167,00 in back taxes and is getting a bill for around $400,000 this month. That bill will include the back taxes, additional property taxes and utility assessments.
The owner narrowly avoided having the mall’s water shut off on Jan. 3 by paying part of the water and sewer fees.
Jack LaMonica, chief of staff for Summit County Fiscal Officer Kristen Scalise, said his office sent several property tax bills to the mall’s owner but has been unable to reach him.
"Kristen just felt – because we were not able to get in touch with the owner – it best served the county to work with the Land Bank to initiate foreclosure," LaMonica said.
Owner Mike Kohan of Kohan Retail Investment Group recently said that he was unaware of the county’s plan to begin a foreclosure. He thinks this is avoidable.
"We’ll pay it," he said. "That’s not a problem."
Kohan Retail Investment Group, though, has had similar struggles at the 27 malls it owns across the country, with some properties shut down intermittently and without warning, and others owing back taxes and utilities or facing sheriff sales and foreclosures. Redevelopment plans often emerge, with a new company stepping in, according to a recent story by MassLive Media, a digital news provider in New England.
While acknowledging these problems, Kohan said his company remains committed to keeping Chapel Hill afloat.
"It’s very hard to overcome all these things with the situation in retail with the market that’s going on," Kohan said.
Mayors weigh in
Tallmadge Mayor David Kline, who noted he doesn’t blame the county for moving toward foreclosure, said he doesn't see how big box retail will survive at that location.
"I think it has to be mixed use," he said.
About 40 businesses on the east side of Brittain Road are located in Tallmadge.
"The businesses have diversified and don't rely as much on the mall, but it's nice having traffic along there," Kline said. "If you lose a big anchor mall, all those businesses along there suffer."
Meanwhile, Cuyahoga Falls Mayor Don Walters said he felt the issues surrounding Chapel Hill Mall were "unfortunate for everyone involved."
"The city of Cuyahoga Falls, much like Akron, is more than willing to work with and help any of the companies that may be displaced to find alternative locations within our city to help keep them running and open for business," added Walters.
Several years ago Kline said he joined Walters and Mayor Dan Horrigan of Akron to meet with Kohan, who had just bought Chapel Hill and said he wanted to make a go of the mall.
"That didn't pan out," Kline said. "He went MIA. The city of Akron affects the whole region. We tried to get the guy to commit to Akron and he never seemed to do that."
Kohan Retail bought Chapel Hill Mall, located on Brittain Road, in July 2016 for $8.6 million.
The mall has struggled recently, facing threats to turn off its utilities three times in the past year. Ohio Edison scheduled and rescinded electricity shutoffs in April and December after accepting late payments.
While a partial payment prevented a Jan. 3 shutoff, the mall’s water and sewer account remains delinquent.
"The city will continue to negotiate with the property owner regarding an appropriate payment plan or additional shut off notices may be issued in the future," the city said in a statement.
Akron had warned mall tenants about the possible water turnoff, which would have meant the shutdown of the mall as well. The mall’s owner similarly provided assurances that the facility would remain open.
Ellen Lander Nischt, Akron’s spokeswoman, said the shutoff was canceled after the owner made a payment. She declined to say how much was paid, citing an exclusion in public record law pertaining to utility bills. She said the city has been negotiating with the mall owner about the delinquent utilities for a year and a "six-figure" amount is still owed.
The mall was going to be assessed $182,280 on its next property tax bill for water, sewer, and street lighting and sweeping fees. After the latest payment, this amount was reduced by $52,000 to $130,280, according to county fiscal office records.
Kohan said the company will satisfy what it owes Akron.
"We’re in good terms and we’ll make that happen," he said.
A foreclosure against Chapel Hill hasn’t been filed yet but the process has begun.
The mall last paid property taxes in January 2019, with a $540,155 payment. Multiple statements sent to the mall’s owner since that date went unanswered, according to the county.
The fiscal office will send a bill in mid-January for $403,418 that will be due Feb. 14. A second property tax bill will be delivered in mid-June, with the payment due in late July.
The amount of the second payment will be based on how much the mall pays toward its debts to the county and city. The combined amount of the two property tax bills this year could be as much as $640,000, according to the fiscal office.
When the fiscal office opted to move forward with a foreclosure, it sought assistance from the Land Bank, a nonprofit established in 2012 to reclaim and rehabilitate vacant and blighted property.
Land Bank Executive Director Patrick Bravo said the agency ordered title work on the mall Dec. 4 and received the information Jan. 2. The agency will now send staff to examine the exterior of the mall and write a report.
This information will be forwarded to the Summit County Prosecutor’s Office for a foreclosure proceeding, which can take several months or much longer.
When Summit County tried to foreclose on Rolling Acres Mall for back taxes, the California-based owners of that Akron mall delayed the process for years by filing repeated bankruptcies.
With Chapel Hill, the owner could pay off his property taxes and avoid foreclosure or go on a payment plan, which puts off foreclosure as long as regular payments are made.
If the foreclosure goes forward, a judge would put the property up for sheriff’s sale. If there are no buyers, the mall could end up with the Land Bank, which could pass it to Akron for redevelopment.
Nischt said Akron will continue working with Kohan with an eye toward possible future plans for the 72-acre mall property, which enjoys an important foothold in the Chapel Hill neighborhood.
"We’re well prepared to support success at that location – whatever that looks like," she said.
The city said in its statement Jan. 3 that the mall site "presents great opportunity for any combination of commercial, residential, retail or light industrial use."
The mall sought to assure customers that it would be open as usual on Jan.3.
"Chapel Hill Mall is open and operating!" the mall said in a Facebook post about 10 a.m., shortly after the mall opened. "Have a wonderful day!"
About 25 stores were open for business Jan. 3, along with two restaurants in the food court. The carousel also was operating. Several die-hard walkers used the mall for exercise.
David Gindlesperger, 63, of Akron, said he and his son are on an exercise kick, so they’ve been walking inside the mall to escape the cold weather.
While he went there to walk, Gindlesperger said he and his family enjoy going to the mall. He said it was sad to see how empty it was on Jan. 3, but he hopes Chapel Hill will find a way to stay open and add more businesses. The mall’s only anchor remaining anchor is J.C. Penney.
Gindlesperger, who has lived in Akron for 40 years, also watched the decline and eventual closure of Rolling Acres Mall, where he met his wife, who worked there in 1977. He was working at a nearby gas station when she came in and they had their first date at a steakhouse at the mall.
Gindlesperger said he hated to see that mall go, and to see Chapel Hill going the same way. He said the mall’s closing is indicative of changing times.
"Everything’s changing, and I don’t think for the better," he said.
Editor’s note: Reporters Laura Freeman and Phil Keren contributed to this story.
Stephanie Warsmith can be reached at 330-996-3705 and email@example.com. Sean McDonnell can be reached at 330-996-3186. Amanda Garrett can be reached at 330-996-3725 and firstname.lastname@example.org.